Skip to main content

How to choose the treatment plan for gallstones? Medication or surgery

 Gallstones are a common clinical disease, especially in middle-aged and obese women. Many patients have no obvious symptoms, or only mild atypical symptoms, such as upper abdominal pain, bloating, fullness after meals, indigestion, etc. There are also many patients who "accidentally" discover gallstones during physical examinations and B-ultrasound examinations.

Then, a series of questions arise: How to choose the treatment plan for gallstones? Do I need to take medicine or surgery? Can medicine cure it? When should I have surgery and what kind of surgery should I have? Is the surgery traumatic? Will there be sequelae? In addition to surgery, are there other ways to remove stones?

Below, we sort out these questions and answer them one by one:

Question 1

What is the natural course of gallstones and are the consequences serious?

1. Asymptomatic gallstones: Most patients with gallstones have no obvious symptoms for a long time. According to the long-term follow-up observation of some patients with asymptomatic gallstones, this group is a benign disease group with a mild course of disease. Few patients will have severe symptoms and require surgery within 10 to 15 years.

2. Symptomatic gallstones: The "symptoms" here refer to severe gallstone-related symptoms such as biliary colic and acute cholecystitis, and do not include general indigestion symptoms. Symptomatic gallstones not only have a significant impact on the patient's life, but studies have also shown that this group has a higher risk of acute cholecystitis, pancreatitis, and biliary obstruction.

3. Possibility of developing gallbladder cancer: Gallbladder cancer is the most serious complication of gallstones. But generally speaking, the possibility of occurrence is very small. Large gallstones, American Indians, porcelain gallbladder and abnormal pancreaticobiliary duct junction are considered to be high-risk factors for gallbladder cancer.

Question 2

After confirming gallbladder stones, what are the basis for choosing a treatment plan?

In the past, there was a tendency to "treat everything" for gallstones, especially with the popularization of laparoscopic technology, which has made this tendency more serious. However, given that the gallbladder has many functions such as storing concentrated bile, regulating bile duct pressure, and building the bile duct immune system, whether surgery is needed should be carefully considered in combination with the patient's specific condition.

Factors that need to be considered when deciding on a treatment plan include: how severe the patient's symptoms are (are the benefits of surgery great?), whether the gallbladder is functioning normally (how big will the side effects of surgery be?), and whether the gallbladder has inflammation, complications, or malignant changes (other factors that increase the necessity of surgery).

Question 3

What treatment options are currently available? What are the pros and cons of each?

1. Cholecystectomy: It is the most accurate and effective method for treating gallstones, and the technology is mature. However, the disadvantage is that the physiological function of the gallbladder is completely lost, and various complications such as bile duct injury, post-cholecystectomy syndrome, and papillary sphincter dysfunction may occur.

2. Cholecystolithotomy: A method of surgically removing gallstones from the gallbladder while preserving the gallbladder. The advantage is that the function of the gallbladder is preserved, but the biggest problem is that the recurrence rate of gallstones is extremely high in the future. Once the gallstones recur, the surgery is in vain!

3. Drug dissolution: If oral drugs can dissolve stones, that would be ideal. Unfortunately, only ursodeoxycholic acid has this effect, and it is limited to 5% to 15% of stone patients (pure cholesterol stones). Studies have shown that even if the stone is successfully dissolved, the recurrence rate in the future is still as high as more than 50%.

4. Extracorporeal shock wave lithotripsy: It was once used as a minimally invasive method in clinical practice. However, it also faces the disadvantages of limited efficacy, high recurrence rate of stones after surgery, and possible liver damage.

Based on the above information, experts in related fields have reached the following consensus on the treatment of gallstones:

1. The treatment of gallstones should be individualized based on factors such as whether the patient has symptoms, whether the gallbladder is functional, whether there is inflammation, whether there are complications, and whether there are conditions for surgery.

2. Patients with asymptomatic or mildly symptomatic gallstones do not need routine preventive cholecystectomy (so-called expectant management).

3. Prophylactic cholecystectomy may be an option for elderly patients in whom expectant management may significantly increase surgical risks.

4. Patients whose symptoms of gallstones significantly affect their work and life or who have had a history of biliary colic, acute cholecystitis, biliary pancreatitis, etc. should undergo elective cholecystectomy.

5. For patients with gallstones who have high risk factors for gallbladder cancer or suspected gallbladder cancer, surgery should be performed regardless of whether they have symptoms.

6. Cholecystectomy is the standard surgical procedure for the treatment of gallstones. If conditions permit, laparoscopic surgery should be the first choice.

7. The practical value of cholecystolithotomy needs further study. Currently, it is only suitable for emergency treatment under acute conditions and is not recommended as an elective surgical procedure. 

8. The cure rates of drug lithotripsy, stone removal therapy, and extracorporeal shock wave lithotripsy are low and may lead to serious complications. They are not currently recommended for

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Bone and joint pain, afraid of surgery and afraid of taking medicine, try these 4 treatments

For many osteoarthritis patients, surgical treatment requires courage, and long-term medication also worries about side effects. Home remedies and natural treatments may help relieve pain, and some may even prevent the condition from progressing. Warm reminder: If you are undergoing some kind of treatment, home remedies cannot replace it. In addition, before you perform the following home remedies, it is best to consult your doctor and choose the best methods based on your individual situation. Hot and cold compresses When pain occurs, hot or cold compresses can be very useful without the side effects of medications. Hot compresses help with stiff joints, while cold compresses are best for treating joint pain. Epsom salt foot bath Pour half a cup of Epsom salts into a small basin and add enough warm water (about 39 degrees) to cover your ankles. Soak your feet for 30-60 minutes. Epsom salts are a good source of magnesium and help regulate the body’s pH levels. Because certain inflammat...

What are elderberries?

 What are elderberries? Miracle berries originating from Europe are highly respected in Western countries for their diverse nutritional value and effects. Elderberry has been used as a medicinal plant as early as ancient Greece. With its unique immunity-boosting and physical-strengthening effects, it has become an essential health product for European families. However, the popularity of elderberries in the Asian market needs to be improved, and many people are still unaware of the nutritional value and potential benefits of elderberries. Why has elderberry been favored by Europeans for so long? What are the magical benefits of elderberries? This article will give you a comprehensive analysis of the effects, nutritional value, consumption methods and precautions of elderberries. If you are also curious about the charm of elderberry, let’s explore the secrets of this natural health treasure together! What are elderberries? Elderberry is a dark purple berry from the Euro...

15 scientific ways to age gracefully in 2025

 Did you know that a 2011 study found a strong link between a positive mindset and good health? It’s just one of many findings that will change the way we think about aging. As we head into 2025, I’m excited to share 15 science-backed ways to enjoy your golden years with energy, confidence, and joy. Key points Maintain a positive attitude and develop a sense of purpose to extend your life and improve your health. Implement a skin care routine that includes sun protection and proven anti-aging ingredients. Nourish your body with a diet rich in fiber, antioxidants, and essential vitamins and minerals. Get regular physical activity, including aerobic exercise and strength training. Prioritize high-quality sleep and effective stress management techniques for optimal aging. Understanding Biological Age vs. Chronological Age Understanding the difference between biological age and chronological age is key  to aging better  . Your  biological...