Skip to main content
Ads-ADVERTISEMENT-1

Is College Still Worth It? How AI, Costs, and Politics Are Rewriting Higher Education in the West

 In an age of rapid technological disruption and information overload, higher education in the West is undergoing a fundamental transformation. For parents and guardians, the pressure to provide meaningful support to young people navigating this uncertain landscape has never been greater.

You don’t need to have all the answers—but listening, asking the right questions, exploring options together, and creating space for multiple conversations over time can make a profound difference in shaping a young person’s future.

It all begins with helping them understand their strengths and interests. Teenagers often struggle to articulate what excites or motivates them, but small conversations about their favorite school subjects or extracurricular activities can lead to important insights.

When that feels unclear, online assessments—widely used across the U.S. and U.K.—can help them sketch an early career profile. Reviewing the results together may reveal recurring themes or highlight interests they hadn’t previously considered. Asking why they are drawn to some paths but not others can be a useful exercise in developing self-awareness and long-term direction.

At the same time, generative AI is rapidly altering the fabric of Western higher education. Harvard Business School now equips all MBA students with ChatGPT EDU accounts and is piloting AI-enhanced coursework.

At Rollins College in Florida, students use AI to co-author scripts in coding classes, boosting engagement and creativity. But not all consequences are positive—research shows that overreliance on AI tools can decrease student performance by up to 17% in traditional, unaided testing environments. In response, universities like SUNY Albany are implementing AI ethics curricula and governance frameworks designed to encourage AI as an enhancer—not a replacement—for human learning.

 For parents, this is a teachable moment: ask your teen what role they believe AI should play in education. Help them think through the balance between technological convenience and critical thinking.

Meanwhile, the economic pressure on institutions is mounting. Since 2020, more than 40 U.S. colleges have permanently closed, and over 20 more are expected to shut down this year alone. Even in the U.K., some experts predict that public universities may enter a period of long-term decline. Leading think tanks like Deloitte and The Chronicle of Higher Education are urging universities to cut low-performing programs and align degrees more closely with labor market demands.

 As a result, students—and their families—must think strategically. It’s no longer just about “getting in” somewhere; it’s about studying something that leads to sustainable, rewarding employment. Fields like AI, data science, nursing, green engineering, and fintech are experiencing rapid growth and high return on investment—making them strong candidates for deeper exploration.

But it’s not just what you study that matters. It’s also how you study. The four-year, on-campus undergraduate model is no longer the default. Schools like Penn State, the University of Maryland, and Arizona State University are expanding hybrid learning options, while institutions like West Texas A&M offer micro-credentials that allow students to gain job-ready skills on more flexible schedules.

For teens who need to work part-time, manage costs, or who aren't ready to commit to a four-year path, these models can be game changers. As a parent, help your child weigh the pros and cons: Are they motivated by traditional campus life? Or would they benefit from earning and learning simultaneously? Does a modular “build-your-own-degree” approach match their goals better than a fixed curriculum?

Ideological battles are also reshaping the higher ed experience. Across the U.S., diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) programs are under scrutiny. Some states are slashing DEI funding, and institutions like MIT have dropped DEI statements as hiring requirements.

 Meanwhile, new institutions such as the University of Austin (UATX) are framing themselves around free speech and meritocracy, rejecting what they view as ideological rigidity. This political undercurrent is shaping how campuses operate and whom they attract. Talk to your child about the kind of intellectual environment they prefer: Are they looking for a values-based, inclusive community, or are they drawn to institutions that emphasize open discourse and independent thinking? Their answer may deeply influence which schools—and majors—feel like the right fit.

At the same time, global competition for talent is intensifying. The U.K.’s university admissions platform, UCAS, reports record application rates among 18-year-olds, with international student interest also rising—especially from China, the U.S., and Ireland. But with rising tuition fees and shrinking government subsidies, both British and American universities face budget constraints that could affect services, course offerings, and student life.

International students and their families must pay close attention to scholarship options, work-study policies, and post-graduation employment pathways like the U.S.’s CPT/OPT or Canada’s Post-Graduate Work Permit. These logistical considerations can determine whether a degree opens real doors—or becomes a costly detour.

Results now speak louder than branding. U.S. graduates with a bachelor’s degree earn, on average, $78,000 per year—$33,000 more than high school graduates—but those figures vary drastically by major.

A degree in petroleum engineering or computer science can yield a six-figure salary, while many humanities graduates struggle to find stable work. Parents should encourage their teens to investigate real-world data: graduate employment rates, internship pipelines, alumni outcomes. Degrees that combine analytical and interpersonal skills—like business analytics, environmental science, and educational technology—are especially promising across both North America and Europe.

Still, concerns over the commercialization of higher education remain. Critics argue that many universities have prioritized luxury dorms, climbing walls, and sports stadiums over academic rigor and student services.

 Families must resist the allure of flashy marketing or high rankings alone. A lesser-known public university may have better employer ties, more accessible professors, and higher ROI. Choosing the right college today is about fit, not fame.

Some universities are responding by introducing lean management practices—streamlining enrollment, administration, and academic workflows. This "Lean Higher Education" approach helps cut costs and improve the student experience. It's another sign that institutions are evolving, and families should look for schools that prioritize not just scale, but agility, service, and support.

Not all internationalization requires travel. Virtual exchanges—via Zoom or shared online projects—are now seen as credible ways to build global experience. For students unable to afford study-abroad programs, these digital interactions still foster intercultural collaboration and professional skills.

Parents should encourage participation in remote internships, international MOOCs, and global hackathons. In an increasingly interconnected world, these low-cost experiences can significantly boost a young person’s profile.

Meanwhile, AI governance is becoming a core part of university policy. International consortia like the Digital Education Council are creating frameworks for how AI should be used and taught responsibly. Higher education is no longer just about absorbing knowledge—it’s about shaping ethical, adaptive citizens who can navigate and influence technological change.

Talk to your teen about these big-picture questions: How does technology affect power? Who should write the rules for algorithms? What does it mean to be a responsible user—and future creator—of technology?

All told, Western higher education is being radically redefined by AI, economic realities, ideological shifts, and global competitiveness. For young people, it’s no longer just a journey to a degree—it’s a multidimensional path of growth in academics, ethics, communication, and adaptability. Parents and guardians can play a crucial role not by prescribing answers, but by enabling discovery.

Your support—through research, reflection, and ongoing dialogue—can help them design a roadmap that blends passion, practicality, and possibility.

In a time where volatility is the norm, emotional intelligence and flexibility are more valuable than prestige alone. If you can offer your child steady encouragement, challenge their assumptions, and co-create a vision for the future, you’ll be giving them something far more enduring than any university brand: the mindset and tools to thrive in a changing world.